Editorial: Saying Something, Saying Nothing

The Burlington Free Press reported last week that “Vermont’s commerce secretary has released the resignation letter for Gene Fullam, the former director of the state’s EB-5 investment program after concluding the letter was improperly withheld from the public.”

The story goes like this. Fullam abrubtly resigned “with no warning and no explanation,” on July 20 after about a year on the high-profile job. He informed his employers of his decision via short, 1.5-line email. Commerce Secretary Pat Moulton refused to release the email, telling the Free Press “It is a personnel matter, which generally are protected matters.”

The Free Press, as daily newspapers are wont to do, filed a public records request for documents connected to Fullam’s resignation. Moulton’s office was supposed to respond within three days but instead took 15. As a bizarre olive branch to make amends for her illegal foot-dragging, Moulton offered the Free Press 30-percent off the $147 fee she wanted to charge to produce the records.

Finally… she forked over 200 pages of emails. Fullam’s 1.5-line email was not among them. Apparently state lawyers told Moulton that Fullam’s email was “personal,” and therefore exempt from public disclosure.

To which Free Press attorney Bob Hemley astutely retorted, “Personal documents are exempt, but being stuck in a personnel file doesn’t make it a personal document.”

Which brings us back to last week’s story. Under pressure from a Free Press legal appeal, Moulton finally released the Fullam email. And what was in this deeply personal correspondence with which the public - Moulton’s employer - couldn’t be trusted?

“Effective today I am formally resigning as Director of the Vermont Regional Center,” Fullam wrote to Moulton. “I appreciate the opportunity to serve and wish you and team the best in future endeavors.”

That’s it. The only thing it tells us is that Moulton and state lawyers are scornful of the public and subscribe neither to the letter, nor the spirit, of Vermont Constitution’s Article Six.

http://www.caledonianrecord.com/opinion/editorial/editorial-saying-something-saying-nothing/article_f3c257ac-e11b-56e9-bc47-a86690777bc6.html

Mentions

• Vermont EB5 Regional Center

States

• Vermont